UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q59 · Numeracy
Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ59
SubjectNumeracy
In a class, there are three groups A, B and C. If one student from group A and two students from group B are shifted to group C, then what happens to the average weight of the students of the class?
- aIt increases.
- bIt decreases.
- cIt remains the same.
- dNo conclusion can be drawn due to insufficient data.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) It remains the same.
The overall average weight depends on the total weight of all students divided by the total number of students in the class, both of which remain unchanged during internal transfers.
Statement-by-statement analysis
✗ Option (a)
- The average weight of the entire class would increase only if new students with higher weights joined the class or existing students gained weight.
- Shifting students between internal groups leaves the total sum of weights and the total student count unchanged.
- Hence, the overall class average weight does not increase.
✗ Option (b)
- The average weight of the class would decrease only if students left the class or existing students lost weight.
- Since no student left or entered the class, the total weight remains constant.
- Hence, the overall class average weight does not decrease.
✓ Option (c)
- Class average weight equals the total sum of weights of all students divided by the total number of students in the class.
- Internal rearrangement of students among groups A, B, and C does not change the total weight of the class or the total number of students.
- Since both the numerator total weight and the denominator total student count remain constant, the average weight remains exactly the same.
✗ Option (d)
- This option is a common trap for candidates who confuse the average weight of individual groups with the average weight of the entire class.
- Information about individual group weights is unnecessary because the question asks about the whole class, not specific groups.
- Therefore, sufficient data is available to conclude that the class average remains unchanged.
Concept to know
- Formula for average weight of a total group is Total Weight divided by Total Number of Students.
- Internal transfer rule states that shifting elements between subgroups of a set does not alter the total sum or total count of the main set.
- To change the overall average of a system, there must be net inflow, net outflow, or external alteration of individual values.
- Always identify the exact population being asked about, whether it is an individual subgroup or the entire combined group.
Related facts for revision
- Weighted average formula where combined average equals the sum of n1 times A1 plus n2 times A2 divided by n1 plus n2.
- Impact of replacement scenarios where an existing person of weight X is replaced by a new person of weight Y.
- Inclusion and exclusion scenarios where adding or removing a member alters the average based on their deviation from the mean.
- Group average changes versus total class average stability during internal reassignments.
How UPSC tests this
Conceptual understanding of overall system averages versus internal group redistributions.
Trap: Candidates often choose option d by overthinking the individual weights of students in groups A, B, and C, failing to realize that internal transfers do not affect the overall class sum.
← Previous · Q58For what value of n, the sum of digits in the number (10^n + 1) is 2?Next · Q60 →How many different sums can be formed with the denominations ₹ 50, ₹ 100, ₹…
More Numeracy PYQs
How many words can one form by shuffling the letters of the word QUEUE, if Q is always followed by U? The words thus formed need not necessarily have any meaning.
See the answer & explanation →
X, Y and Z jump forward 4', 6' and 5', respectively. At 8 AM, they all land on mark 199'. How many times will they all land on the same mark (need not be at the same moment) between mark 195' and 1000', if all of them cross mark…
See the answer & explanation →
A toy T jumps forward or backward. In each forward jump, it moves 5' forward whereas in each backward jump, it moves 2' backward. If in 31 jumps, T moves exactly 15' forward, then what is the difference of the number of forward…
See the answer & explanation →
If 10^m × 1000 × n = 75^25 × 25^32 × 32^75, where n is not divisible by 10, then the value of m is
See the answer & explanation →Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.