UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q23 · Comprehension
People will invest in education whenever they are granted the economic freedom to fully enjoy its benefits. Again, this is for the obvious reason that the return on education increases as the level of economic freedom rises. When people, thanks to lower tax rates, are allowed to retain most of the higher income that they gain from each incremental level of education, it makes eminent sense to invest in education. On the other hand, when the government decides to tax the higher income of educated individuals at even higher rates, it makes very little sense to invest in educating oneself further. The same incentives apply to parents who decide on whether to invest in their children's education.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Lower tax rates in a country invariably translate into greater investments in higher education.
2. Investment in the education of children ensures their economic freedom.
3. Economic freedom has a positive impact on building up human capital.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- c3 only
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Economic freedom encourages investment in education, which forms human capital, while statements 1 and 2 rely on extreme absolutes and reversed causal logic.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage notes that lower taxes make education investment sensible, but it does not mean lower taxes invariably lead to greater investment in every instance.
- The statement narrows the scope to higher education, whereas the passage speaks generally about education at all levels.
- The passage posits that economic freedom leads to investment in education, not that investing in education guarantees or ensures economic freedom.
- This statement reverses the cause-and-effect relationship established in the text and uses the extreme word ensures.
- Education is a core component of human capital formation.
- Since the passage argues that economic freedom increases incentives to invest in education, it logically assumes that economic freedom positively impacts human capital building.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that must be true for the author's core argument to hold valid.
- Extreme qualifiers such as invariably, always, only, or guarantees usually render an assumption invalid in CSAT comprehension.
- Do not confuse cause and effect: if A leads to B in the passage, assuming B automatically guarantees A is a logical fallacy.
- Identify core concepts: education and skill acquisition implicitly equate to human capital formation in economic passages.
- Use the Negation Test: if negating a statement destroys the main argument of the passage, that statement is a valid assumption.
Related facts for revision
- Assumption versus Inference questions in CSAT Reading Comprehension
- Identifying extreme words and scope shifts in passages
- Negation test technique for validating assumptions
- Cause-and-effect directionality traps in logic questions
Ability to identify essential implicit premises without falling for extreme language or cause-effect reversals.
Trap: Candidates often select Statement 1 because lower taxes are mentioned in the passage, overlooking the word invariably and the unwarranted shift to higher education.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.