UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q25 · Comprehension
Our urban bodies cannot possibly ensure sustainable delivery of water in our cities unless financing mechanisms are put in place. Water delivery requires heavy investment in collecting it from a natural source, treating it to make it potable, and laying a distribution network of pipes for delivery to the users. It also requires investments in sewerage infrastructure and sewage treatment plants so that the sewers can carry the wastewater to these plants to ensure that no untreated sewage is discharged back into natural water bodies. If our cities were rich enough to meet the entire cost, water could be delivered free. They are not.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Rich cities only can ensure sustainable delivery of water.
2. Sustainable delivery of water in cities means much more than supplying water to households.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Assumption 2 is implicit because sustainable water delivery requires both supplying treated water and managing wastewater infrastructure, whereas Assumption 1 is invalid due to the extreme word 'only' and misinterpreting financing mechanisms as requiring cities to be rich.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that financing mechanisms are needed for sustainable water delivery and mentions that rich cities could deliver water free of cost.
- It does not imply that only rich cities can achieve sustainable water delivery, as non-rich cities can do so by establishing proper user charges or financing mechanisms.
- The use of the restrictive word 'only' makes this assumption logically invalid and unsupported by the text.
- The passage explicitly links sustainable water delivery to heavy investments in water collection, treatment, pipe networks, as well as sewerage infrastructure and sewage treatment plants.
- This demonstrates that sustainable water delivery encompasses the complete ecological and infrastructure cycle, going far beyond merely supplying water to households.
Concept to know
- Identifying Assumptions: An assumption is an unstated implicit premise that the author must believe to be true for the argument to hold logically valid.
- Extreme Language Trap: Words like 'only', 'always', 'never', or 'must' often render an assumption invalid unless explicitly backed by the context.
- Distinguishing Assumption from Inference: An inference is a logical conclusion derived from stated facts, while an assumption is a foundational background belief supporting the argument.
- Scope Verification: Ensure that the assumption stays strictly within the logical boundary set by the passage without introducing outside opinions.
- Negation Test: If negating the assumption destroys the author's primary argument, then that assumption is valid; if the argument survives, the assumption is invalid.
Related facts for revision
- Critical Message / Main Idea Questions: Focus on identifying the central theme or takeaway of the passage rather than underlying assumptions.
- Logical Inference Questions: Require identifying facts that naturally follow from the given premises without assuming extra details.
- Implication Questions: Examine the future consequences or broad policy outcomes suggested implicitly by the text.
- Negation Technique in CSAT: Testing assumptions by assuming the opposite statement and checking if the passage's thesis collapses.
Evaluating implicit assumptions and recognizing absolute language traps in UPSC comprehension passages.
Trap: Option (c) is a common trap because candidates equate the need for heavy financial investment with requiring cities to be rich, ignoring that financing mechanisms like user fees allow non-rich cities to fund water infrastructure.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.