EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q26 · Comprehension

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ26
SubjectComprehension

In India, agriculture still engages about half of its workforce, and about 85 per cent of its farms are small and marginal. Compared to China and Vietnam, which have experienced fast structural and rural transformation, India's story is of slow transformation. As a result, poverty reduction in India was at a much slower pace during 1988-2014, compared to China and Vietnam. India's poverty reduction was slow during 1988-2005, but during 2005-2012, it accelerated dramatically—almost three times faster than during the earlier period. What did India do during this period? Research reveals that the relative price scenario changed significantly (by more than 50%) in favour of agriculture in the wake of rising global prices. This boosted private investments in agriculture by more than 50%. As a result, agri-GDP growth touched 4.1% during 2007-2012 as against 2.4% during 2002-2007. The net surplus of agri-trade touched $25 billion in 2013-2014; real farm wages rose by 7% per annum. All this led to unprecedented fall in poverty.

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Structural and rural transformation is impossible when farms are mainly small and marginal.
2. A good price incentive can trigger investments in agriculture.
3. India needs to build value chains for high-value agri-products like livestock and horticulture.
4. Higher global prices of agricultural commodities are essential for India's poverty reduction.
Which of the above assumptions are valid?

  1. a1 and 3
  2. b2 and 4
  3. c2 and 3
  4. d3 and 4
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) 2 and 3

Statement 2 is directly supported by the passage, while Statements 1 and 4 contain extreme qualifiers (impossible, essential) that make them invalid, leaving Option (c) via elimination.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement 1
  • The passage notes that structural transformation in India has been slow compared to China and Vietnam, but does not state that small farm sizes make transformation impossible.
  • The word impossible is an extreme qualifier that renders the statement logically invalid.
✓ Statement 2
  • The passage explicitly mentions that a favourable shift in relative prices boosted private investment in agriculture by over 50 percent.
  • This directly confirms the assumption that good price incentives can trigger agricultural investment.
✓ Statement 3
  • Building value chains for high-value agriculture supports structural and rural transformation discussed in the passage.
  • Eliminating Statements 1 and 4 leaves Statement 3 as part of the only valid option pair.
✗ Statement 4
  • The passage shows that global price increases helped boost growth during 2005-2012, but does not assert that high global prices are mandatory for all poverty reduction in India.
  • The word essential is an extreme qualifier that makes this assumption invalid.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated premise required for an argument to hold true, which must be logically necessary and non-extreme.
  • Watch out for extreme qualifiers such as impossible, essential, always, or never, as they usually make options invalid in CSAT comprehension.
  • Distinguish between a contributing factor and an essential condition; rising global prices helped in one period, but are not essential for all poverty reduction.
  • Apply the elimination technique systematically when evaluating multi-statement options to isolate the correct pair quickly.
  • Ensure valid assumptions align with the passage core theme of price incentives driving private investment and agricultural growth.

Related facts for revision

  • Assumption vs Inference: Assumptions are unstated underlying premises, whereas inferences are logical conclusions derived directly from stated facts.
  • Extreme modifier traps: Words like completely, impossible, essential, or only are frequently used to craft incorrect choices.
  • Passage scope boundary: Avoid bringing outside knowledge into passage questions unless eliminating extreme false options leaves a contextual statement.
  • Main argument identification: Isolating the core thesis helps determine which underlying beliefs are necessary to sustain the argument.
How UPSC tests this

Critical reading comprehension, evaluating validity of assumptions, and spotting extreme language traps.

Trap: Selecting Statement 4 because global prices are mentioned in the text, while overlooking the restrictive word essential. Eliminating extreme words immediately narrows down the options.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.