UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q6 · Comprehension
Although most of the Genetically Modified (GM) crops cultivated now are genetically engineered for a single trait, in future, crops genetically engineered for more than one trait will be the norm. Thus, biotechnology's role in agriculture and the regulation of the same cannot be understood solely in the context of the current generation of GM crops. Instead, there is a need to take a comprehensive look, taking into account various aspects, including socio-economic impacts, so that the potential of the technology can be harnessed while minimizing negative impacts. Given the importance of biotechnology in developing varieties that can help in climate change mitigation and adaptation, not using biotechnology as a part of the climate change action plan cannot be an option. Domestic regulation of biotechnology cannot be viewed in isolation of trade policy and obligations under various international treaties and conventions.
Which one of the following statements best implies the crux of the passage?
- aPrecautionary principle is not given importance in current debate on developing GM crops.
- bBiotechnology is not currently used in climate change mitigation and adaptation mechanisms.
- cBiotechnology's role is not confined to the current priorities of developing GM crops.
- dThe negative impacts of biotechnology are not properly understood.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly states that biotechnology's role and regulation cannot be understood solely in the context of current GM crops, highlighting its broader scope including climate change and socio-economic aspects.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage discusses minimizing negative impacts, but it does not mention the precautionary principle or claim it is being ignored.
- This option introduces an external concept not mentioned or implied in the text.
- The passage states that using biotechnology in climate change mitigation and adaptation cannot be avoided.
- It does not claim that biotechnology is currently not being used in climate change mechanisms.
- The text directly highlights that biotechnology's role in agriculture cannot be understood solely in the context of the current generation of GM crops.
- It emphasizes a broader role encompassing future multi-trait crops, climate change action, socio-economic impacts, and international trade policy.
- The passage advocates taking a comprehensive look to minimize negative impacts while harnessing potential.
- It does not state or imply that the negative impacts are not properly understood.
Concept to know
- Identifying the crux or main idea requires isolating the central argument that ties all sentences together.
- Distinguish between direct passage assertions, reasonable inferences, and external assumptions.
- Eliminate options that use extreme language or introduce jargon not present in the given text.
- Focus on transition and conclusion words such as Thus, Instead, or cannot be understood solely to locate the author's primary thesis.
- Ensure the chosen answer reflects the holistic scope of the passage rather than a single supporting detail.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea and Crux Questions: Summarizing the overarching thesis of a reading passage.
- Tone and Scope Identification: Evaluating whether the author takes a balanced, critical, or supportive stance.
- Out of Scope Distortion Traps: Avoiding options that sound true in general knowledge but are not anchored in the text.
Ability to synthesize the central theme of a text and discard options based on external knowledge.
Trap: Options (a) and (d) sound plausible in the context of real-world GM crop debates, but they are not stated or implied in the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.