UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q1 · Comprehension
In India, over the last decade or so, labour has been departing agriculture, but is only going to construction and unregistered manufacturing which are not markedly better jobs. Services, where labour tends to be most productive, are not generating the additional jobs the country needs. India will need 24 million or so jobs over the next decade. The new sector, e-commerce, can at best close only half the jobs gap. Only those sectors that drive domestic demand such * as health and education can comfortably fill the other half.
Which one of the following is best implied in the passage?
- aStrong measures need to be taken to reduce the rural to urban migration of labour.
- bThe working condition in construction and unregistered manufacturing needs to be improved.
- cService sector has been reducing the problem of unemployment.
- dIncreased social sector spending is imperative for large-scale job creation.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Health and education are primary components of the social sector, and filling half of the 24 million job gap through them necessitates increased spending in these areas.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage mentions labour departing agriculture but nowhere recommends restricting rural-to-urban migration.
- Restricting migration is an external policy suggestion not discussed or implied by the author.
- The passage states that construction and unregistered manufacturing are not markedly better jobs to highlight their low quality.
- It does not argue that improving working conditions in these sectors will solve the overall 24 million job deficit.
- This option directly contradicts the passage, which explicitly states services are not generating the additional jobs the country needs.
- High productivity in services does not translate to high job creation according to the text.
- Health and education represent key components of social sector spending.
- Filling half of the 24 million required jobs (12 million jobs) via health and education logically implies that scaling up social sector expenditure is mandatory.
Concept to know
- Connect specific examples in the text to their broader umbrella terms, such as mapping health and education to social sector spending.
- Evaluate the quantitative scale mentioned in the text where filling 12 million jobs constitutes large-scale job creation.
- Distinguish between explicit statements and underlying logical implications derived directly from the premises.
- Reject options that introduce external real-world solutions not backed by the author's main argument.
- Identify the core requirement needed to achieve the outcome stated in the final sentence of the passage.
Related facts for revision
- Implication versus assumption questions in UPSC CSAT reading comprehension.
- Categorization of specific sector data into general socio-economic heads.
- Eliminating options based on real-world plausibility when unsupported by text.
- Evaluating necessary conditions for large-scale economic outcomes.
Ability to synthesize specific examples into broader categories and infer logical prerequisites.
Trap: Candidates often select option (b) because improving working conditions sounds like a good policy, even though the passage never advocates for it.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.