UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q62 · Comprehension
India has tremendous potential for solar energy. We all realize that we have to stop burning fossil fuels to meet our energy needs. But certain renewable resources are still going through their cost curves and learning curves to get the required amount of output. The Indian Government has strongly committed to its targets of reducing emissions by 33 per cent by 2030, and towards this it has initiated a strong push towards a gas-based economy and has also invested heavily in renewable energy. However, business houses are wary of investing too heavily in renewable energy at a time when the technology is not yet ready.
Which one of the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?
- aIndia's commitment to reduce emissions by 33% is unlikely to be achieved.
- bIndia should import gas rather than invest in renewable resources.
- cGetting renewable resources to market too soon may be costly.
- dIndia should put in more efforts in the exploration of natural gas.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage notes that renewable technologies are still on their cost and learning curves and technology is not yet ready, implying premature market entry could be financially unviable or costly.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage highlights India's strong commitment to its 33 percent emission reduction target and its active policy push.
- Claiming that the target is unlikely to be achieved is an extreme and unsupported speculation not backed by the passage.
- The passage mentions a push towards a gas-based economy but says nothing about importing gas as a substitute for renewables.
- Recommending gas imports over renewable investment introduces an external idea outside the text scope.
- The passage explicitly states that renewable resources are still going through their cost curves and learning curves.
- It highlights that business houses hesitate because the technology is not yet ready, directly inferring that deploying these resources too soon could be costly.
- Domestic exploration of natural gas is nowhere mentioned or implied in the provided text.
- Recommending increased efforts in gas exploration brings in extraneous outside knowledge.
Concept to know
- In CSAT reading comprehension, a logical inference must be strictly derived from the premises provided in the text without assuming unstated facts.
- Understand terms like cost curves and learning curves, which indicate that unit costs decrease as production volume and technological experience accumulate over time.
- Avoid options that offer far-fetched policy recommendations or speculative predictions not directly supported by the passage.
- Eliminate distractors that introduce external topics not covered in the text, such as fuel imports or resource exploration.
- Identify the option that logically connects the passage premises regarding technological unreadiness and high cost.
Related facts for revision
- Distinguishing explicit facts from logical inferences and implicit assumptions in CSAT.
- Handling economic and environmental policy-themed passages in aptitude tests.
- Identifying scope-exceeding options vs text-bound conclusions.
- Understanding learning curve economics in technology adoption passages.
Ability to deduce logical conclusions based strictly on provided economic and technological premises.
Trap: Options (a) and (d) tempt candidates by introducing realistic real-world policy options that are nonetheless completely absent from the passage text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.