EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q72 · Numeracy

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ72
SubjectNumeracy

A car travels from a place X to place Y at an average speed of v km/hr, from Y to X at an average speed of 2v km/hr, again from X to Y at an average speed of 3v km/hr and again from Y to X at an average speed of 4v km/hr. Then the average speed of the car for the entire journey

  1. ais less than v km/hr
  2. blies between v and 2v km/hr
  3. clies between 2v and 3v km/hr
  4. dlies between 3v and 4v km/hr
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) lies between v and 2v km/hr

The total distance is 4d and the total time is 25d / 12v, giving an average speed of 1.92v km/hr, which lies between v and 2v km/hr.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Calculates to an average speed of 1.92v, which is greater than v km/hr.
  • Rules out the possibility of the average speed being less than v.
✓ Option (b)
  • Average speed equals Total Distance divided by Total Time, which is 4d divided by (25d / 12v) = 48v / 25 = 1.92v km/hr.
  • Since 1.92v lies strictly between 1v and 2v, this option is correct.
✗ Option (c)
  • Calculates to 1.92v km/hr, which is strictly less than 2v km/hr.
  • Therefore, the average speed does not fall between 2v and 3v km/hr.
✗ Option (d)
  • Calculates to 1.92v km/hr, which is significantly less than 3v km/hr.
  • Therefore, the average speed does not fall between 3v and 4v km/hr.

Concept to know

  • Average speed for any multi-leg journey is defined as total distance covered divided by total time taken.
  • When equal distances are traveled at different speeds, average speed is given by the Harmonic Mean of those speeds, not the Arithmetic Mean.
  • The Arithmetic Mean of speeds v, 2v, 3v, 4v would yield 2.5v, which incorrectly overestimates the true average speed.
  • To solve quickly, assume a convenient distance d equal to the LCM of the speed coefficients (1, 2, 3, 4), which is 12 units.
  • With distance d = 12 units, individual times taken are 12/v, 6/v, 4/v, and 3/v, making total time equal to 25/v units.
  • Dividing total distance of 48 units by total time of 25/v units yields average speed = 48v / 25 = 1.92v km/hr.

Related facts for revision

  • Harmonic mean formula for two equal distances at speeds a and b is 2ab / (a + b).
  • Harmonic mean formula for n equal distances is n divided by the sum of reciprocals of individual speeds.
  • Average speed is always strictly less than the Arithmetic Mean of speeds when speeds are unequal.
  • If time intervals of each leg are equal instead of distances, average speed equals the simple Arithmetic Mean of the speeds.
How UPSC tests this

Understanding average speed concepts, harmonic mean applications, and basic algebraic simplification.

Trap: Assuming average speed is the simple arithmetic mean (v + 2v + 3v + 4v)/4 = 2.5v, which wrongly points to option (c). Using LCM for distance saves calculation time.

More Numeracy PYQs

All Numeracy questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.