UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q17 · Data Sufficiency
Two Statements S1 and S2 are given
below followed by a Question :
S1: There are not more than two figures
on any page of a 51-page book.
S2: There is at least one figure on every
page.
Question:
Are there more than 100 figures in
that book?
Which one of the following is correct in
respect of the above Statements and the
Question?
- aBoth S1 and S2 are sufficient to answer the Question, but neither S1 alone nor S2 alone is sufficient to answer the Question.
- bS1 alone is sufficient to answer the Question.
- cS1 and S2 together are not sufficient to answer the Question.
- dS2 alone is sufficient to answer the Question.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Even when combining both statements, the total number of figures can range from 51 to 102, which does not uniquely determine whether there are more than 100 figures.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Combining both statements establishes that each of the 51 pages has either 1 or 2 figures.
- The total number of figures ranges from 51 to 102.
- Because the total could be 90 (answering No) or 101 (answering Yes), combining S1 and S2 fails to give a definitive answer.
- Statement 1 states there are at most 2 figures per page, giving a maximum of 51 × 2 = 102 figures.
- There is no lower bound specified, so the total could be 0, 50, or 102.
- Statement 1 alone is insufficient to answer if there are more than 100 figures.
- Statement 1 provides an upper limit of 102 figures (51 × 2).
- Statement 2 provides a lower limit of 51 figures (51 × 1).
- Together, the total figures can be any integer from 51 to 102, which straddles the threshold of 100 and yields no unique Yes/No answer.
- Statement 2 states there is at least 1 figure on every page, giving a minimum of 51 × 1 = 51 figures.
- There is no upper bound, so the total could be 51, 100, or 500.
- Statement 2 alone is insufficient to answer the question.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency Core Principle: A statement or set of statements is sufficient only if it leads to a single, unambiguous Yes or No answer.
- Lower Bound Calculation: Statement 2 requires at least 1 figure per page, giving Minimum Total = 51 × 1 = 51 figures.
- Upper Bound Calculation: Statement 1 allows at most 2 figures per page, giving Maximum Total = 51 × 2 = 102 figures.
- Evaluating Range vs Threshold: The derived range of total figures is 51 to 102 inclusive.
- Inconclusiveness: Since the range contains values less than or equal to 100 (e.g., 51 to 100) and values greater than 100 (101 and 102), the data is insufficient.
Related facts for revision
- Definite No is Sufficient: In Data Sufficiency, if data conclusively proves the answer is No, the data is still sufficient.
- Boundary Value Testing: Always calculate extreme cases (minimum possible and maximum possible) when dealing with inequalities.
- Threshold Straddling Trap: If a calculated range crosses the target number, the statements combined are insufficient.
- Question Types: Similar CSAT problems involve bounds on average scores, total weights, or item counts across pages or containers.
Ability to calculate range bounds from inequalities and evaluate if they yield a unique binary response in Data Sufficiency.
Trap: Assuming that having both lower and upper limits automatically makes the information sufficient, without checking if the range straddles the target threshold of 100.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.