UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q24 · Comprehension
Our urban bodies cannot possibly ensure sustainable delivery of water in our cities unless financing mechanisms are put in place. Water delivery requires heavy investment in collecting it from a natural source, treating it to make it potable, and laying a distribution network of pipes for delivery to the users. It also requires investments in sewerage infrastructure and sewage treatment plants so that the sewers can carry the wastewater to these plants to ensure that no untreated sewage is discharged back into natural water bodies. If our cities were rich enough to meet the entire cost, water could be delivered free. They are not.
What is the most logical and crucial message conveyed by the passage?
- aUrban local bodies must recover costs through user charges.
- bUrban local bodies are not efficient enough to meet the water requirements of our cities.
- cWater shortage in our cities is a perennial problem that cannot be solved.
- dIn view of the water crisis in our cities, there is an urgent need to limit the population of cities by adopting an upper limit of population size.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage asserts that water infrastructure requires heavy investment and cities are not rich enough to provide water for free, logically implying that costs must be recovered through user charges.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The text highlights that water delivery and sewage treatment require heavy investments.
- It explicitly states that cities are not wealthy enough to bear the full cost and deliver water free.
- Hence, establishing financing mechanisms via user charges is the necessary logical conclusion for sustainable delivery.
- The passage focuses entirely on financial constraints and infrastructure costs, not on managerial or operational inefficiency.
- Attributing the problem to inefficiency distorts the main premise of the passage.
- The author suggests that sustainable delivery is possible if financing mechanisms are put in place.
- Labeling the water shortage as an unsolvable perennial problem contradicts the conditional solution provided in the text.
- Limiting city population size is an external policy suggestion not mentioned or implied anywhere in the passage.
- The passage discusses funding infrastructure to meet existing needs rather than restricting demographic growth.
Concept to know
- Identify the core premise: Read the passage to determine the primary cause and effect relationship established by the author.
- Locate the logical bridge: The text states heavy investment is needed, cities cannot afford to give water free, and financing mechanisms are mandatory.
- Distinguish between explicit statements and necessary inferences: A logical message connects stated premises to their unstated but inescapable practical requirement.
- Avoid external knowledge traps: Eliminate options that introduce policy measures like population caps not discussed in the text.
- Eliminate extreme or defeatist options: Passages proposing conditional solutions do not support conclusions stating a problem is permanently unsolvable.
Related facts for revision
- Crucial message versus main idea questions: Crucial message questions require identifying the actionable takeaway, whereas main idea questions focus on summarization.
- Assumptions versus inferences: An assumption is an unstated premise required for the argument to hold, while an inference is a logical consequence of the text.
- Extraneous information trap: Options introducing reasonable real world solutions that are absent from the text must be rejected.
- Tone analysis: Identifying whether the author tone is analytical, practical, or alarmist helps rule out overly pessimistic options.
Ability to derive the central actionable logical message from a set of financial and infrastructural premises.
Trap: Option (b) attracts candidates who confuse financial incapacity with operational inefficiency, while Option (d) traps those bringing in outside knowledge about urban population pressure.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.