EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q2 · Comprehension

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ2
SubjectComprehension

In India, the current focus on the right to privacy is based on some new realities of the digital age. A right is a substantive right only if it works in all situations, and for everyone. A right to free expression for an individual about her exploitation, for instance, is meaningless without actual availability of security that guarantees that private force cannot be used to thwart this right. The role of the State, therefore, is not just to abstain from preventing rightful free expression, but also to actively ensure that private parties are not able to block it.

On the basis of the above passage, the following assumptions have been made:
1. State should have some institutions to ensure its appropriate role in a digital society.
2. State should ensure that private parties do not violate the citizens' right to privacy.
3. Digital economy is not compatible with the idea of not violating the citizens' privacy.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?

  1. a1 and 2
  2. b3 only
  3. c1 and 3
  4. d2 only
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) 1 and 2

Statements 1 and 2 are valid assumptions required for the State to actively protect rights against private interference, whereas Statement 3 is an extreme claim unsupported by the passage.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Statement 1
  • The passage emphasizes that the State must actively ensure private parties cannot thwart fundamental rights in a digital society.
  • For the State to carry out an active role in enforcing and safeguarding rights, having appropriate regulatory or legal institutions is an essential underlying premise.
  • Therefore, Statement 1 is a valid assumption.
✓ Statement 2
  • The author links the focus on privacy to digital age realities and argues that the State must prevent private forces from blocking rights.
  • Using free expression as an illustrative example, the passage establishes the general rule that substantive rights like privacy must be protected from private violations.
  • Therefore, assuming the State should protect citizens' right to privacy against private party violations is directly valid.
✗ Statement 3
  • The passage notes that digital realities bring new focus to privacy, but it does not claim that the digital economy is fundamentally incompatible with privacy.
  • Assuming total incompatibility is an extreme over-generalization that goes far beyond the text.
  • Therefore, Statement 3 is an invalid assumption.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated, underlying premise that the author must accept as true for their main argument to hold.
  • Use the Negation Test: if negating a statement destroys the passage's main thesis, that statement is a valid assumption.
  • Be cautious of extreme words like incompatible, impossible, or completely which often render an assumption invalid unless explicitly justified.
  • Recognize that when an author prescribes an active duty to an entity like the State, the presence or need for mechanisms to fulfill that duty is implicitly assumed.
  • Distinguish between illustrative examples used in a passage (such as free expression) and the broader principle being argued (protection of substantive rights like privacy).

Related facts for revision

  • Evaluating assumptions vs inferences vs central corollaries in CSAT Reading Comprehension.
  • Identifying scope boundary traps where options introduce logical extremes not supported by the text.
  • Analyzing passages on regulatory framework, fundamental rights, and digital governance.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to identify implicit logical premises while rejecting unstated extreme generalizations.

Trap: Candidates often discard Statement 1 because the word institutions is not explicitly written in the passage, forgetting that assumptions are by definition unstated necessities.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.