EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q33 · Reasoning

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ33
SubjectReasoning

Two Statements are given followed by two Conclusions :
Statements :
All cats are dogs.
All cats are black.
Conclusion-I :
All dogs are black.
Conclusion-II :
Some dogs are not black.
Which of the above Conclusions logically follows/follow from the two given Statements, disregarding commonly known facts?

  1. aOnly Conclusion-I
  2. bOnly Conclusion-II
  3. cNeither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II
  4. dBoth Conclusion-I and Conclusion-II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) Neither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II

Neither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II logically follows because both represent possibilities rather than definite conclusions derived from the given statements.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Conclusion-I states All dogs are black.
  • From the statements All cats are dogs and All cats are black, we only know that the dogs which are cats are black.
  • Dogs outside the cat set may or may not be black, so Conclusion-I is not definitely true.
✗ Option (b)
  • Conclusion-II states Some dogs are not black.
  • It is possible that all dogs are black without violating either of the two given statements.
  • Since this is only a possibility and not a certainty, Conclusion-II does not definitely follow.
✓ Option (c)
  • Neither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II is guaranteed to be true in all valid Venn diagram configurations.
  • Since neither conclusion follows individually as a matter of logical certainty, option c is correct.
✗ Option (d)
  • Conclusion-I (All dogs are black) and Conclusion-II (Some dogs are not black) are mutually contradictory statements.
  • Both conclusions cannot be true at the same time under any interpretation.

Concept to know

  • Syllogism questions are evaluated based on strict logical deduction where a conclusion must be true in every valid Venn diagram scenario.
  • Representing statements as sets: Cat set (C) is a subset of Dog set (D), and C is also a subset of Black set (B).
  • The overlap guarantees that the intersection of D and B is non-empty, which means Some dogs are black is a valid conclusion.
  • The status of dogs that are not cats regarding blackness remains unknown, allowing both All dogs are black and Some dogs are not black as mere possibilities.
  • When a statement represents only a possibility across valid Venn diagrams, it cannot be claimed as a definite conclusion.

Related facts for revision

  • Immediate conversion rules: All A are B converts validly to Some B are A and Some A are B.
  • Complementary pairs: Universal Positive (All A are B) and Particular Negative (Some A are not B) form an either-or relation when neither is individually definite.
  • Venn diagram strategy: Always test both minimal overlap and maximum overlap scenarios to check if a conclusion holds universally.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to deduce strictly valid logical conclusions using syllogism rules and Venn diagrams without making unwarranted assumptions.

Trap: Candidates often assume that because cats are a subset of dogs, non-cat dogs must not be black, leading them to pick Conclusion-II. Always treat unmentioned regions as uncertain.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.