EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q21 · Comprehension

Year2020
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ21
SubjectComprehension

Private investment in general is volatile. Foreign private investment is more volatile because the available investment avenues are significantly greater (i.e., the entire world). Therefore, the responsibility of providing employment cannot be left to Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). The current FDI inflows are volatile over time and across sectors and regions, which is a necessary consequence of their search for the highest returns. The adverse consequences are unstable employment and an accentuation of income and regional inequalities. A probable positive consequence of foreign investment is the inflow of new technology and its subsequent diffusion. However, the technology diffusion is not at all certain because the existing state of physical and human capital in India may prove inadequate for the diffusion.

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Relying on foreign investment in the long run is not an economically sound policy.
2. Policies must be undertaken to reduce volatility in foreign private investment.
3. Policies must be undertaken to strengthen domestic private investment.
4. Public investment should be given priority over private investment.
5. Substantial public investment in education and health should be undertaken.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?

  1. a1, 2 and 4
  2. b1, 3 and 5
  3. c2, 4 and 5
  4. d3 only
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) 1, 3 and 5

Statements 1, 3, and 5 logically follow as valid underlying assumptions regarding the inherent risks of FDI and the necessity of building domestic investment and human capital.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Statement 1
  • Passage notes that FDI is highly volatile and leads to unstable employment and regional inequalities.
  • This implies that relying on foreign investment in the long run is not economically sound.
✗ Statement 2
  • Passage explicitly states that volatility is a necessary consequence of foreign investment searching for the highest returns worldwide.
  • It is not assumed that domestic policies can simply reduce this inherent global market volatility.
✓ Statement 3
  • Because employment responsibility cannot be left to volatile foreign investment, domestic private investment must be strengthened to sustain economic stability.
✗ Statement 4
  • Passage does not advocate prioritizing public investment over all private investment in general.
  • It only highlights specific limitations of foreign private investment regarding employment and technology diffusion.
✓ Statement 5
  • Passage states that technology diffusion is uncertain due to inadequate physical and human capital in India.
  • Building human capital logically assumes substantial public investment in education and health.

Concept to know

  • Assumption identification requires finding unstated premises that must be true for the author's logic to hold.
  • Logical connection between stated bottlenecks (inadequate human capital) and basic policy requirements (investment in education and health).
  • Recognizing stated constraints: If volatility is a necessary consequence of global capital, suppressing it through domestic policy is not a valid assumption.
  • Elimination strategy: Rejecting statements that make overbroad generalizations not implied by the text (such as prioritizing public over all private investment).

Related facts for revision

  • Evaluating implicit assumptions versus explicit inferences in reading comprehension.
  • Distinguishing between author's facts, warnings, and underlying policy assumptions.
  • Using elimination of contradictory options to solve multi-statement comprehension questions efficiently.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to identify valid implicit assumptions underlying socio-economic arguments.

Trap: Choosing Statement 2 under the belief that policy should fix volatility, ignoring the passage note that volatility is an unavoidable feature of return-seeking foreign capital. Eliminating Statement 2 immediately narrow options to (b) and (d).

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.