UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q36 · Data Sufficiency
Three Statements S1, S2 and S3 are given below followed by a Question :
S1 : C is younger than D, but older than A and B.
S2 : D is the oldest.
S3 : A is older than B.
Question :
Who among A, B, C and D is the youngest?
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Statements and the Question?
- aS1 alone is sufficient to answer the Question.
- bS1 and S2 together are sufficient to answer the Question.
- cS2 and S3 together are sufficient to answer the Question.
- dS1 and S3 together are sufficient to answer the Question.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements S1 and S3 together give the complete descending order of age as D > C > A > B, uniquely identifying B as the youngest.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- S1 gives D > C > A and D > C > B, showing that the youngest person is either A or B.
- S1 does not provide a direct age comparison between A and B.
- Therefore, S1 alone is insufficient to determine the unique youngest person.
- S1 establishes D > C > A and D > C > B, which already implies D is older than all others.
- S2 states D is the oldest, adding no new information to S1.
- The relative ordering between A and B remains unknown, making S1 and S2 together insufficient.
- S2 states D is the oldest, leaving the relative order of A, B, and C unknown.
- S3 states A > B, but provides no relation involving C.
- C could be younger than B or older than B, so S2 and S3 together are insufficient.
- S1 establishes D > C > A and D > C > B, meaning C is older than both A and B.
- S3 establishes A > B, placing A above B in age.
- Combining S1 and S3 yields the exact order D > C > A > B, uniquely determining B as the youngest person.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency evaluates whether the given statements provide minimal required information to arrive at a unique answer.
- Step 1 translates each statement into mathematical inequalities or ordering relations among the variables.
- Step 2 checks if a single statement uniquely answers the question; if not, test combinations of statements.
- Avoid solving further once a unique complete or partial ordering answers the specific question asked.
- Redundant statements add no new constraints and should be eliminated when looking for minimal sufficient combinations.
Related facts for revision
- Inequality-based linear arrangement problems involving height, weight, marks, or age.
- Checking for redundancy where one statement is a logical subset of another statement.
- Questions asking for extreme positions like maximum, minimum, oldest, or youngest versus finding full rank order.
- Distinguishing between definite sufficiency where one unique answer emerges versus positional ambiguity.
Logical ordering and evaluating minimal data sufficiency without unnecessary calculations.
Trap: Option (b) is a common trap because S2 seems useful, but S2 is completely redundant since S1 already establishes that D is older than C, A, and B.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.