UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q63 · Comprehension
India has tremendous potential for solar energy. We all realize that we have to stop burning fossil fuels to meet our energy needs. But certain renewable resources are still going through their cost curves and learning curves to get the required amount of output. The Indian Government has strongly committed to its targets of reducing emissions by 33 per cent by 2030, and towards this it has initiated a strong push towards a gas-based economy and has also invested heavily in renewable energy. However, business houses are wary of investing too heavily in renewable energy at a time when the technology is not yet ready.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Governments often provide inefficient and costly subsidies for technologies that may not be ready in the near future.
2. India's commitment of reducing emissions by 33% by 2030 shall be on the basis of gas-based economy.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement 1 is a valid assumption as the passage highlights heavy government funding in unready technology despite market hesitation, while Statement 2 incorrectly assumes emission reduction depends solely on a gas-based economy.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that the government has invested heavily in renewable energy even though the technology is not yet ready and business houses are wary of investing.
- This implies an underlying assumption that governments frequently step in to fund or subsidize premature technologies despite high costs and potential short-term inefficiencies.
- Therefore, Statement 1 logically underpins the author's observation about heavy state expenditure on developing technology.
- The passage mentions both a push towards a gas-based economy and heavy investments in renewable energy as combined efforts to reduce emissions.
- Assuming that emission reduction shall be strictly on the basis of a gas-based economy ignores the parallel push towards renewable energy mentioned in the text.
- The restrictive phrasing 'shall be on the basis of' creates an overly narrow assumption not supported by the multi-pronged approach in the passage.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated prerequisite or underlying belief that the author relies upon to make their explicit argument.
- Identify implicit assumptions by examining actions taken by actors like governments and inferring the logic that justifies those actions.
- Watch out for extreme or restrictive terms such as 'shall be', 'only', or 'solely' that convert a multi-component strategy into a single dependency.
- Distinguish between explicit factual statements directly written in the passage and background assumptions required for the argument to hold.
- Reject assumptions that contradict explicit details or impose exclusive conditions not warranted by the text.
Related facts for revision
- Assumption vs Inference questions: Inferences are conclusions drawn from stated facts, while assumptions are unstated foundations of the text.
- Extreme modifier traps: Words like 'always', 'never', 'must', and 'shall' frequently signal invalid options in CSAT comprehension.
- Evaluating policy arguments: Recognize how public sector risk-taking often contrasts with private market risk aversion in economic passages.
- Multi-variable reasoning: When a passage presents multiple solutions to a problem, assuming reliance on only one solution is logically invalid.
Evaluating underlying assumptions and identifying restrictive or exclusive claims in reading comprehension.
Trap: Choosing Statement 2 simply because 'gas-based economy' appears in the text, failing to notice that the statement makes it the exclusive basis for emission reduction.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.