UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q65 · Comprehension
Many people understand the connection between solid waste management and health in terms of the consequences of unattended heaps of dry garbage which become home for flies and other vermin. However, there is another aspect that is not well-understood, that is, what happens when unscientific solid waste management combines with poor drainage and dumping of untreated sewage into drains which are meant to carry storm water during rains. The result is choked drains which are full of stagnant water breeding mosquitoes, resulting in the spread of water-borne diseases.
In the context of India, which one of the following statements best reflects the critical message of the passage?
- aIn India, the drainage networks are not separate for sewerage and storm water.
- bUrban local bodies do not have enough resources and legislative authority to deal with the problems of waste management.
- cSolid waste management should be integrated with the maintenance of drainage and sewerage networks.
- dBad management of solid waste and sewerage systems by our municipalities is the reason for drinking water shortages in our cities.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that solid waste management interacts with poor drainage and sewage issues to cause health hazards, implying the need for an integrated management approach.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that untreated sewage is dumped into storm water drains, describing a misuse of drains rather than asserting that separate networks do not exist in India.
- This describes an operational failure rather than capturing the main action-oriented message of the passage.
- The passage makes no reference to the financial resources or legislative powers of urban local bodies.
- Bringing in external facts about municipal administrative limitations makes this option out of scope.
- The passage explains how unscientific solid waste management combines with poor drainage and sewage dumping to cause stagnant water and water-borne diseases.
- The critical message or key takeaway is that solid waste management cannot succeed in isolation and must be integrated with the maintenance of drainage and sewerage systems.
- The passage connects choked drains and stagnant water to the breeding of mosquitoes and spread of water-borne diseases, not to drinking water shortages.
- Attributing drinking water scarcity to waste mismanagement distorts the cause-and-effect relationship given in the text.
Concept to know
- Critical message questions in reading comprehension require identifying the main actionable takeaway or central policy lesson of the passage.
- Distinguish between explicit factual descriptions of problems and implicit core takeaways that offer integrated solutions.
- Eliminate distractors that introduce outside real-world information not present in the text, such as municipal funds or legislative authority.
- Verify the exact health or environmental outcomes mentioned in the text to avoid choosing options with misattributed consequences.
- Recognize that when a passage details how multiple infrastructure failures compound each other, the overarching message points toward integrated management.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea questions requiring candidates to encapsulate the central theme without over-focusing on secondary details.
- Crucial Policy Implication questions where candidates infer the most logical systemic solution to a described failure.
- Assumption questions where the unstated premise behind the author's argument must be identified.
- Common distractor types including out-of-scope statements, factual distortions, and overly narrow summaries.
Ability to synthesize a multi-factor problem described in a passage into its primary logical conclusion or policy takeaway.
Trap: Option (a) traps candidates who confuse an instance of misuse described in the passage with an official statement about infrastructure design in India.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.