UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q41 · Comprehension
Spanish ships in the late 16th century first brought the potato tuber from South America to Europe whereby in the early 19th century, it had become a reliable backup to cereal crops, particularly in the cold, rain-soaked soils of Ireland. The Irish were soon almost wholly dependent on the potato as their staple food. And they were planting primarily one prodigious variety, the 'Lumper' potato, whose genetic frailty would be cruelly exposed by the fungus 'Phytophthora infestans'. In 1845, spores of the deadly fungus began spreading across the country, destroying nearly all the Lumpers in its path. The resulting famine killed or displaced millions.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the critical message of the passage?
- aFor introducing any foreign plant into a country, the soil and climate conditions of that country should be suitable.
- bAs a staple food of a country, tuber crops like potato cannot replace cereal crops.
- cSome of the fungal infections of plants cannot be prevented or stopped from spreading across large areas.
- dRelying on a homogeneous food source is not desirable.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage illustrates how total reliance on a single, genetically uniform crop variety (the Lumper potato) led to catastrophic vulnerability and mass famine when attacked by a fungus.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage shows that Ireland's soil and climate were indeed suitable for growing potatoes.
- The catastrophe occurred due to genetic frailty and monoculture, not climate or soil unsuitability.
- The passage states that the potato successfully became a reliable staple food in Ireland.
- The vulnerability arose because they relied on a single variety of potato, not because tuber crops are inherently inferior to cereals.
- While fungal infections caused the crop loss, this option focuses on a narrow biological detail rather than the broader lesson.
- The critical message lies in avoiding over-reliance on a single homogeneous crop to prevent such disasters.
- The passage explicitly connects total dependence on one single variety ('Lumper' potato) to genetic frailty and devastating famine.
- It highlights the existential risk of agricultural monoculture, making the lack of crop diversity the central warning.
Concept to know
- Identifying the critical message of a passage requires isolating the overarching lesson or takeaway rather than secondary factual statements.
- Monoculture or crop homogeneity refers to cultivating a single variety of crop across a large area, which drastically reduces genetic diversity.
- Genetic frailty in homogeneous crops makes an entire population uniformly susceptible to a single disease or pest outbreak.
- Distinguishing between explicit facts (e.g. fungal spread) and the implicit main lesson (risk of single-crop dependence) is vital in CSAT Reading Comprehension.
- Eliminate options that make unstated generalisations, such as claiming tuber crops can never replace cereal crops.
Related facts for revision
- Assumptions vs Inferences vs Critical Messages: Critical messages ask for the primary normative takeaway intended by the author.
- Biodiversity and food security concepts in Ecology, where crop diversification acts as a hedge against widespread agricultural failure.
- Main Idea questions in CSAT: Incorrect choices often highlight minor details, over-generalise specific facts, or contradict passage text.
- Tone and intent evaluation: Authors describe historical disasters to warn readers against repeating similar systemic vulnerabilities.
Ability to synthesize passage details into a high-level critical takeaway or overarching message.
Trap: Selecting Option (c) because it mentions fungal infections, which appears directly in the passage, but misses the core normative warning about monoculture.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.