UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q5 · Comprehension
Although most of the Genetically Modified (GM) crops cultivated now are genetically engineered for a single trait, in future, crops genetically engineered for more than one trait will be the norm. Thus, biotechnology's role in agriculture and the regulation of the same cannot be understood solely in the context of the current generation of GM crops. Instead, there is a need to take a comprehensive look, taking into account various aspects, including socio-economic impacts, so that the potential of the technology can be harnessed while minimizing negative impacts. Given the importance of biotechnology in developing varieties that can help in climate change mitigation and adaptation, not using biotechnology as a part of the climate change action plan cannot be an option. Domestic regulation of biotechnology cannot be viewed in isolation of trade policy and obligations under various international treaties and conventions.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. Biotechnology regulation is an evolving process.
2. Participation of people is needed in policy decisions regarding biotechnology regulation.
3. Biotechnology regulation should take into account socio-economic aspects in decision-making.
4. Wider involvement of political executive in biotechnology regulation improves its effectiveness in dealing with the country's trade policies and international obligations.
Which of the above assumptions are valid?
- a1, 2 and 4 only
- b1 and 3 only
- c2, 3 and 4 only
- d1, 2, 3 and 4
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statements 1 and 3 are valid underlying assumptions derived directly from the passage, whereas statements 2 and 4 introduce external ideas not assumed by the author.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that biotechnology regulation cannot be understood solely in the context of current GM crops because future crops will have multiple traits.
- This implies the underlying assumption that regulation is an evolving process that must continuously adapt to future technological shifts.
- Although the passage emphasizes evaluating socio-economic impacts, it does not explicitly assume or state that direct public participation is required in policy decisions.
- Assuming people's participation introduces an external concept not implied as a necessary prerequisite by the author.
- The passage explicitly highlights the need to take a comprehensive look taking into account socio-economic impacts to harness technology while minimizing negative effects.
- This directly validates the assumption that decision-making in biotechnology regulation should incorporate socio-economic aspects.
- The passage states that domestic regulation cannot be viewed in isolation from trade policy and international treaties.
- However, it does not assume that wider involvement of the political executive improves effectiveness, making this an unsupported assertion.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must hold to be true for their main argument to remain logically valid.
- Distinguish between facts stated in the passage, logical inferences, and unstated assumptions required by the text.
- Avoid outside knowledge bias, such as introducing real-world policy terms like public participation or political executive when absent from the premise.
- Watch out for specific organizational terms that are not grounded in the author's reasoning.
- Apply the negation test: if negating the assumption makes the passage's core argument collapse, the assumption is valid.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying valid implicit assumptions versus direct explicitly stated conclusions.
- Negation test technique for critical reasoning and assumption questions in CSAT.
- Filtering out extreme keywords or out-of-scope concepts in reading comprehension.
- Distinguishing between an inference (logical outcome) and an assumption (underlying premise).
Ability to spot valid unstated assumptions based strictly on passage premises while rejecting out-of-scope statements.
Trap: Choosing options containing plausible real-world ideas, such as people's participation or political executive involvement, which are not assumed by the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.