UPSC Prelims 2020 CSAT Q3 · Comprehension
One of the biggest ironies around water is that it comes from rivers and other wetlands. Yet it is seen as divorced from them. While water is used as a resource, public policy does not always grasp that it is a part of the natural ecosystem. Efforts at engineering water systems are thus efforts at augmenting water supply rather than strengthening the capacities of ecological systems.
Which one of the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?
- aRivers and other wetlands should be protected under Ramsar Convention.
- bEngineering water systems should be modernized and further augmented.
- cWetlands need to be reinforced as more than just open sources of water.
- dWater supply should not be free of cost so as to prevent its misuse or overuse.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
It correctly captures the core passage message that wetlands must be treated as integrated ecological systems rather than mere open sources for water supply.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage discusses ecological systems and public policy generally.
- Specific international treaties like the Ramsar Convention are not mentioned or implied in the text.
- Introducing external real-world knowledge violates the rules of reading comprehension inferences.
- The passage explicitly criticizes engineering efforts for focusing narrowly on augmenting supply.
- Suggesting further augmentation contradicts the passage emphasis on strengthening ecological capacities.
- Modernization of engineering alone does not solve the fundamental flaw in policy perspective identified in the passage.
- The passage notes that water is treated merely as a resource and divorced from ecological systems.
- It highlights that current efforts focus on supply augmentation rather than strengthening natural ecological capacities.
- Therefore, the logical inference is that wetlands must be reinforced as complex ecological systems beyond being simple water extraction sources.
- Pricing of water, cost structure, or preventing misuse through fees is nowhere discussed in the passage.
- This option introduces an external policy prescription not supported by the given text.
- Logical inferences must strictly stay within the scope of the premises provided in the passage.
Concept to know
- In reading comprehension inference questions, the correct option must logically follow from the given premises without introducing unstated outside facts.
- Identify the core problem presented in the passage, which here is treating water as an isolated economic resource rather than an ecological system.
- Differentiate between explicit statements, valid logical inferences, and external real-world knowledge.
- Eliminate options that recommend actions directly criticized by the passage, such as further focusing solely on supply augmentation.
- Ensure the conclusion directly addresses the author's primary concern regarding public policy blind spots.
Related facts for revision
- Inference vs Assumption: An inference is a logical conclusion derived directly from given facts, whereas an assumption is an unstated premise required for an argument to hold.
- Out-of-bound traps: Options mentioning famous treaties, laws, or specific policy measures not stated in the passage are common distractors.
- Author sentiment analysis: Identifying whether the author views engineering-only solutions positively or critically helps rule out options like (b).
Ability to draw a precise logical inference from a passage without importing external domain knowledge.
Trap: Option (a) attracts candidates because the Ramsar Convention is a famous real-world wetland protection treaty, but it is absent from the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.